A small victory
for democracy occurred on January 8, 2013. The Mullett Township Board responded
favorably to 170 people, who were brave enough to stand up to the Topinabee
Development Association’s strangle-hold on the local government by signing a
petition drafted by Patty King last July to save the Topinabee Athletic Club swings
in the park. It was not a one-sided, winner take all victory, but a victory of compromise
done in a democratic fashion.
David Ogg, a
TDA board member and one half of the public participation on the Mullett Township
Park’s Committee, with his wing-man Tom O’Hare seated by his side, presented
his anti-swing argument and started as usual with “I knew nothing about the
park” and that the previous Board was “adamant” that they did not want the liability
of the TAC swings.
This was the continuation of the falsity perpetrated by these
two individuals working behind closed doors with the park designers to remove
forever a set of swings that were gifted at no cost to the residents of Mullett
Township by the late Topinabee Athletic Club. Mr Ogg ignored the fact his park redesign
incorporates a large grouping of age specific playground equipment that has a
larger footprint than the TAC swings. Mr Ogg’s playground equipment also includes
climbing and overhead bars that have more than twice the injury rate of public swings
for those age groups who will use Mr Ogg’s playground.
Ignoring
this, Mr Ogg went on to falsely state that there was no room in the park redesign
for the swings. The TAC swings were there before Mr Ogg saw the park and were
only crowded out by a redesign that was driven by aesthetics, putting beauty
before practicality; while ignoring both the historical and practical use of
the park by the public. Had this park redesign gone through adequate public hearings
and input meetings, preliminary designs, and further meetings to actually show
people outside of the TDA board what was happening, this situation would not
have occurred.
Beaches are
beaches. Water and sand, some grass for tossing a ball, and a few picnic tables
are the necessities. The TAC swings were just a plus and have been enjoyed by
all. Playgrounds are increasingly age specific, do not need to be a part of a
beach-front park, and almost never are because they add both liability and maintenance
costs.
David Ogg
stated that the choice was between handi-capped access and the swings, between
green grass and the swings, between picnic tables and the swings, or between the
trees in the park and the swings. I‘m thankful he did not make the Mullett Board
choose between motherhood, apple pie, baseball and the TAC swings. As I dozed
off I am sure I heard the choices were between a candy bar and an ice cream cone
and did I want the ice cream cone now or later? It’s a cruel thing to put candy
bars and ice cream cones in our heads after the market has closed.
Mr Ogg also threatened
and attempted to thwart the option of adding a new smaller 2 or 4 swing-set by
stating it might cost the entire approved project. I think one of Mr Ogg’s park
attractions; the ADA viewing/fishing platform has disappeared. If so, it
apparently did not kill the project. If a viewing platform is or isn’t in the
plan could be stated more accurately
if any member if the public had seen a final to-be-built plan for this $400,000
capital project.
Mr Ogg
stated a 2 swing unit might be accommodated with the loss of one tree, but a 4
swing, that typically would require less than 400 square feet more space, would
require removal of all the trees. The tree-hugger card does not play well after
personal observation of the TDA sponsored spring clean-up crew cutting every young
tree along the park shore in 2012.
Despite Mr
Ogg’s do you want a candy bar little boy arguments, we are thankful that the Mullett
Township Board listened to the people of all ages who signed a petition with over
170 names and their heart-felt comments.
The Board
passed a motion to install either a 2 swing or hopefully a 4 swing unit within
the new park. Whether the swings are installed as the park is built or after is
not important, the important thing is people will still find a few swings in
the park to be enjoyed by all.